How to stop procrastinating: what the research says works

Across 19 controlled studies, people given help with procrastination ended up clearly less stuck, and where studies checked back, the gain held for up to six months. Which help stood out, and what to try this week.

Yappie टीम9मि पढ़ें
A small pale ceramic pot with one young green seedling on a white windowsill, soft blue sky blurred in the window behind, in bright cool daylight.
इस पृष्ठ पर
  1. What the research can tell you
  2. Which kind of help stood out
  3. What goes with putting things off
  4. What to try this week
  5. Where Yappie fits
  6. References

The best-tested answer is not a trick but structured help that works on how you think about a task and how you go about it. A 2018 review pooled 19 studies, mostly small and mostly of students, that each compared people given such help (training or therapy lasting one to 24 hours in all) with a comparison group, most of them on a waiting list (van Eerde & Klingsieck, 2018, pp. 77, 81 to 82). The people helped ended up clearly less stuck. By our approximate translation, the average person helped finished less stuck than roughly 7 in 10 people in the comparison group (p. 79). In the 12 comparisons that checked back against a comparison group, one week to about six months later, the gain had not shrunk (p. 80). The one kind of help that tested better than the others pooled together was cognitive behavioural: spotting the thought that keeps you from the task, checking it, and replacing it. The authors call that finding preliminary (pp. 81 to 82).

What the research can tell you

A lot of procrastination advice has never been tested. Two reviews are worth leaning on instead. One pools studies that tested ways of helping people procrastinate less.1 A meta-analysis pools the results of many earlier studies into one overall estimate, so it can say something none of them could alone. ↩ The other pools hundreds of studies on what goes with procrastinating.

The first is van Eerde and Klingsieck's, published in Educational Research Review, a solid journal below the top shelf, covering studies from 1979 to 2017 (p. 81). Twenty-four studies measured change before and after help. Five had no comparison group, and people change over time without help, so the authors set those aside and kept the 19 that did (Fig. 1, p. 77; p. 79). Across those, the group given help improved more than the comparison group did, by about 0.65 standard deviations,2 A standard deviation is the usual spread between people on a questionnaire, and 0.65 of one is a medium-to-large effect by the usual rule of thumb. The figure compares how much each group changed. Our rough translation, assuming both groups started level: the average person helped ended up less stuck than about 7 in 10 of the comparison group. The two standard conversions give about 68 and 74 in 100, so treat "7 in 10" as approximate. ↩ a figure that leaves out one outlier; with the outlier left in, it is 0.62 (p. 79).

That outlier was an unpublished study of smartphone self-monitoring for bedtime procrastination, the only smartphone study in the review, and its helped group fared far worse than its comparison group (pp. 76, 79 to 80, 83). The authors removed it from the headline number (p. 79).

Of the 34 comparisons in the headline, 28 came from student samples (p. 81). In the 12 comparisons that checked back against a comparison group, between a week and about six months later, the helped group's lead had not shrunk: from the end of the programme to the follow-up, the difference between the groups barely moved (p. 80). In the authors' words, "the findings suggest that people can change" (p. 81).

Which kind of help stood out

The authors sorted every programme into one of four types (p. 78), then asked whether each type did better or worse than the other three pooled (Table 1, p. 81). This compares groups of studies, not methods head to head, so it is not a league table:

The four types of help in van Eerde and Klingsieck (2018), compared with the other three pooled
Type of help Comparisons What the review found
Cognitive behavioural (CBT) 11 Tested better than the rest pooled; the authors call this preliminary and say it may reflect how intensive these programmes were
Self-regulation, including time management and emotion regulation 13 Not different from the rest
Other therapeutic approaches (for example paradoxical or acceptance-based) 8 Not different from the rest
Strengths and assertiveness training 2 Did worse, from two studies that disagreed with each other; the authors urge the same caution as for CBT

CBT rests on the idea that thoughts shape feelings and behaviour, so the work is identifying the thought, checking whether it helps or gets in the way, correcting it, and turning the corrected thought into action (p. 78). Its 11 comparisons came out about 0.95 standard deviations better than their comparison groups, against 0.65 for all 34, and varied less from study to study (p. 81). The authors call this "preliminary only": the programmes mixed several methods, which made them hard to label, and CBT's larger effect may come from how intensive those programmes were (p. 82).

Self-regulation training, a broad group that includes time management and emotion regulation, did not test differently from the rest (pp. 78, 81). Not standing out is not the same as failing, though the paper does not report this group's own average. The authors note that time management usually does not address emotions and may not be enough on its own, which is why it is often combined with other approaches (p. 78).

What goes with putting things off

Piers Steel's 2007 review in Psychological Bulletin, a top-tier journal, pools 691 correlations from 216 works (p. 73). It maps what goes with procrastinating rather than testing what stops it, mostly from questionnaires answered by young university students (p. 74). We covered it in What actually goes with procrastination. Two findings and one piece of his theory matter here.

Intending is not what is missing. Procrastinators report intending to work about as much as anyone: across eight studies the correlation is −.03, a near-zero and imprecise estimate (Table 5, p. 78; p. 79). It is the idea behind why starting is hard: the trouble is the move from intending to starting.

The task itself matters. How unpleasant a task is goes with how much it is put off (.40 across eight studies), and people who procrastinate more find more of life's chores unpleasant (also .40, across ten) (Table 2, p. 75). This finding is also backed by experiments Steel cites: the more boring and difficult researchers made a task, the more likely people were to delay it (p. 75). Impulsiveness (.41) and distractibility (.45) also go with putting things off, and self-control goes the other way (−.58): the more of it, the less delay (Tables 4 and 5, pp. 77 to 78). Perfectionism, the usual suspect, came out at −.03 for putting off starting, across 24 studies, though that figure leaves out the kind where you feel other people set your standards, which Steel puts at .18, pooled with other fears of failing (Table 3, p. 76; p. 81).

In Steel's theory, distance matters too: the desire to do a task stays low while its reward is far off and climbs as the deadline nears (pp. 71 to 72).

What to try this week

This list is ours. It is built from the CBT description, from Steel's findings on unpleasant tasks and from his reasoning about distraction, and no study tested these exact steps as written.

  1. Write down the sentence you tell yourself about the task, then ask whether it is true. "This will take all day and I will do it badly" is a thought you can check. That is our version of the identify-and-check step (p. 78). It is a prompt, not a treatment.
  2. Shrink the start until it stops feeling unpleasant, for example to "open the file and write one line". That size is our guess. What Steel reports is that unpleasant tasks go with more delay, and that in experiments he cites, making a task more boring and harder made delay more likely (p. 75).
  3. Move the easiest temptation out of reach before you begin. Steel's own example is e-mail: over 90 percent of college computer users, in a study he cites, reported using it to delay irrationally, and he reasons that making it less visible or slower to reach should decrease procrastination (p. 82). That is his prediction from the evidence, not a finding of his review.
  4. Use a planner if you like one, but do not expect it to carry the whole job. Self-regulation training, the group that includes time management, did not test differently from the rest, and the authors note that time management usually leaves the emotional side alone (pp. 78, 81).

Pick one for a week, then look at what changed. The research cannot tell you which one suits you.

Where Yappie fits

We make Yappie, so weigh this as an interested party. It is a focus timer with a pet beside you. On the free plan it has a timer and tasks you can break into small steps, on Windows and macOS. Breaking a task into small steps fits item 2. It does nothing for the thought-checking in item 1, and it does not block distracting apps, so item 3 is up to you. None of it was tested in the studies above, and the review's one smartphone study came out worse than its comparison group. Treat Yappie as a place to try item 2, not a treatment.

References

  1. van Eerde, W., & Klingsieck, K. B. (2018). Overcoming procrastination? A meta-analysis of intervention studies. Educational Research Review, 25, 73 to 85. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.edurev.2018.09.002↩
  2. Steel, P. (2007). The nature of procrastination: A meta-analytic and theoretical review of quintessential self-regulatory failure. Psychological Bulletin, 133(1), 65 to 94. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-2909.133.1.65↩

इस पोस्ट को साझा करें

XLinkedInFacebookWhatsApp